Choosing the right roofing material is a major decision for homeowners in Union, Washington, Festus, St. Clair, Herculaneum, Gerald, Fenton, Valley Park, DeSoto, Pevely, and Eureka. The two most common options—asphalt shingles and metal roofing—each have unique benefits. To make an informed choice, homeowners should conduct a thorough asphalt metal roofing comparison to determine which material best suits their budget, durability needs, and aesthetic preferences.
An asphalt metal roofing comparison considers factors such as cost, longevity, energy efficiency, maintenance, and weather resistance. Whether you prioritize affordability, long-term value, or minimal upkeep, this guide will help you decide which roofing option is best for your home.
Why an Asphalt Metal Roofing Comparison Matters
Missouri’s climate presents challenges for homeowners. From heavy rains and strong winds to extreme summer heat and winter snowfall, roofs must be built to withstand a variety of conditions. Conducting an asphalt metal roofing comparison ensures that homeowners choose a roof that will perform well for decades.
Durability and Longevity
Asphalt Shingles: Dependable but Limited Lifespan
- Lifespan: 20-30 years
- Weather Resistance: Moderate; vulnerable to wind, hail, and heavy rain
- Maintenance Needs: Regular inspections and occasional shingle replacement
- Fire Resistance: Standard asphalt shingles have moderate fire resistance unless treated with special coatings
Metal Roofing: Highly Durable and Long-Lasting
- Lifespan: 40-70+ years
- Weather Resistance: Excellent; designed to withstand extreme temperatures, high winds, and impact damage
- Maintenance Needs: Minimal upkeep with occasional inspections
- Fire Resistance: High; metal roofs are naturally fire-resistant
In an asphalt metal roofing comparison, metal roofing clearly lasts longer and withstands severe weather better. Homeowners in storm-prone areas like Eureka, Union, or Fenton may find metal roofing the best long-term investment.
Cost Analysis
Asphalt Shingles: Lower Upfront Cost
- Material Cost: $3.50 – $5.50 per square foot
- Installation Cost: More affordable due to easier installation
- Long-Term Expenses: Higher maintenance costs and earlier replacement
Metal Roofing: Higher Initial Investment, Lower Lifetime Cost
- Material Cost: $7.00 – $15.00 per square foot
- Installation Cost: More expensive due to specialized labor
- Long-Term Savings: Lower maintenance costs, fewer repairs, and longer lifespan
While asphalt shingles are initially cheaper, an asphalt metal roofing comparison shows that metal roofing may be more cost-effective over time due to its durability and minimal upkeep.
Installation Time and Complexity
Asphalt Shingles: Faster and Easier Installation
- Installed in 1-3 days
- Less labor-intensive
- Suitable for DIY installation (though professional installation is recommended)
Metal Roofing: Requires Expertise and Precision
- Installation takes 3-7 days
- Requires skilled professionals for proper fitting
- Improper installation can lead to expansion/contraction issues
For homeowners who need a quick, budget-friendly roofing solution, asphalt shingles are the easier choice. However, in an asphalt metal roofing comparison, metal roofing offers superior performance if properly installed.
Energy Efficiency and Environmental Impact
Asphalt Shingles: Moderate Energy Performance
- Absorbs heat, leading to increased cooling costs in summer
- Available in reflective coatings to improve efficiency
- Contributes to landfill waste, as asphalt shingles are not easily recyclable
Metal Roofing: Superior Energy Efficiency
- Reflects sunlight, reducing cooling costs by up to 40%
- Can be made from recycled materials and is fully recyclable
- Compatible with solar panels for further energy savings
For homeowners in hot climates like Valley Park, Pevely, or DeSoto, an asphalt metal roofing comparison highlights metal roofing as the best option for reducing energy costs.
Curb Appeal and Aesthetic Options
Asphalt Shingles: Classic and Versatile
- Wide range of colors and textures
- Complements traditional home designs
- Less expensive to customize
Metal Roofing: Modern and Stylish
- Available in standing seam, corrugated panels, and shingle-like designs
- Multiple colors and finishes available
- Enhances home resale value
In an asphalt metal roofing comparison, asphalt shingles are more common and blend easily with most home styles, while metal roofing adds a modern, high-end look.
Weather Resistance in Missouri
Asphalt Shingles: Less Durable in Harsh Weather
- Can be damaged by winds over 60 mph
- Prone to granule loss, especially in heavy rain or hail
- More susceptible to mold and mildew in humid conditions
Metal Roofing: Superior Protection Against the Elements
- Withstands winds up to 140 mph
- More resistant to hail and impact damage
- Does not absorb moisture, preventing mold and leaks
For homeowners in storm-prone areas like Washington, Festus, and Herculaneum, an asphalt metal roofing comparison shows that metal roofing offers better protection against severe weather.
Maintenance Requirements
Asphalt Shingles: Requires Regular Inspections and Repairs
- Needs periodic replacement of damaged shingles
- Susceptible to moss and algae growth
- Shorter lifespan means higher maintenance costs over time
Metal Roofing: Low Maintenance and Long-Lasting
- Requires occasional inspections for loose fasteners
- Resistant to mold, mildew, and pests
- More cost-effective in terms of upkeep
When considering long-term maintenance, an asphalt metal roofing comparison proves that metal roofing requires significantly less upkeep than asphalt shingles.
Noise and Soundproofing
Asphalt Shingles: Naturally Quieter
- Absorbs sound from rain and hail
- Provides better sound insulation
Metal Roofing: Can Be Noisier Without Proper Insulation
- Rain and hail can be louder on metal roofs
- Additional insulation or underlayment can reduce noise
For homeowners who prioritize a quiet indoor environment, an asphalt metal roofing comparison suggests that asphalt shingles have the advantage unless additional insulation is used with metal roofing.
Resale Value and Homebuyer Appeal
Asphalt Shingles: Standard but Less Valuable Over Time
- Buyers expect asphalt shingles due to their widespread use
- Resale value impact depends on the roof’s condition
Metal Roofing: Higher Resale Value
- Increases home value due to durability and efficiency
- Attracts buyers looking for long-term investment
An asphalt metal roofing comparison suggests that homeowners looking to maximize resale value should consider metal roofing over asphalt shingles.
Which Roofing Option is Best for Your Home?
Choose Asphalt Shingles If:
- You need an affordable roofing solution with lower upfront costs
- You prefer a traditional look that blends with most home styles
- You’re okay with replacing the roof in 20-30 years
Choose Metal Roofing If:
- You want a long-term investment with minimal maintenance
- You need superior weather resistance for Missouri’s climate
- You’re looking for an energy-efficient solution to lower utility bills
Final Thoughts on Asphalt Metal Roofing Comparison
Homeowners in Union, Washington, Festus, St. Clair, Herculaneum, Gerald, Fenton, Valley Park, DeSoto, Pevely, and Eureka must weigh the benefits of asphalt shingles and metal roofing carefully. An asphalt metal roofing comparison shows that while asphalt shingles are more affordable and easier to install, metal roofing offers unmatched longevity, weather resistance, and energy savings.
Investing in the right roofing material ensures long-term protection, comfort, and value. Whether homeowners choose asphalt shingles for their affordability or metal roofing for its durability, an asphalt metal roofing comparison helps make an informed decision that meets both short-term and long-term needs.
